Chlamydia Screening Programs: A Review of
the Literature. Part 1: Issues in the Promotion of Chlamydia Testing
of Youth by Primary Care Physicians
Alexander McKay, Sex Information and Education Council of Canada
(SIECCAN)
Rates of Chlamydia are highest among 15- to 24-year-old females.
Often asymptomatic, untreated chlamydia can lead to Pelvic Inflammatory
Disease (PID) and result in infertility, ectopic pregnancy, chronic
pelvic pain, and increased susceptibility to HIV infection. Screening
at risk women for chlamydia and treating those who test positive
reduces the incidence of PID. This article reviews key data and
research related to Chlamydia screening of youth by primary care
physicians. These issues include the prevalence of chlamydia, the
cost-effectiveness of chlamydia screening programs, the need to
test males for Chlamydia, the discrepancy between guidelines for
screening and the reality of physician screening practices as well
as research on factors associated with the likelihood of physician
Chlamydia screening of youth aged15-24 and factors associated with
the likelihood of physicians conducting sexual health risk assessments
with their patients. The data and research reviewed in this article
highlight the need for increased primary care physician Chlamydia
screening of youth and identify issues that need to be addressed
in interventions designed to increase and improve physician Chlamydia
screening practices (The Canadian Journal of Human Sexuality,
2006; 15: 1-11).
Chlamydia Screening Programs: A Review of the Literature.
Part 2: Testing Procedures and Educational Interventions for Primary
Care Physicians
Mary Bissell, Sex Information and Education Council of Canada (SIECCAN)
Taking Action on Chlamydia Campaign, a social marketing campaign
designed by Toronto Public Health, was implemented in response to
rising rates of infection among young adults in the Toronto area.
In the first phase of the project, the goal has been to reach primary
care physicians with educational messages related to the prevalence
of chlamydia infection, the need for screening, and the current
testing practices available. The following literature review addresses
two areas of research relevant to the first phase of the project:
(1) elements of successful educational interventions designed to
change physician clinical practices and patient outcomes and (2)
the accuracy and acceptability of chlamydia/STI screening tests.
The research regarding educational interventions for primary care
physicians in outlined in Section I. The importance of multifaceted
approaches to learning is clearly indicated in the literature. The
use of a single method of information delivery is less effective
than a combination of methods that motivate, facilitate and reinforce
positive behavioural change among physicans in a clinical setting.
Section II focuses on the current state of screening tests used
in the diagnosis of chlamydia infections. The accuracy of available
tests is discussed, as is the acceptability of various forms of
testing among both physicians and patients (The Canadian Journal
of Human Sexuality, 2006; 15:
13-22).
Sexual Ideology and Sexual Physiology in the Discourses
of Sex Advice Literature
Erin Connell and Alan Hunt, Carleton University
This paper explores the connection between changing knowledge of
sexual physiology and normative prescriptions about gendered roles
within sexual relations. An analysis of marital/sexual advice literature
reveals a profoundly gendered construction of male and female roles
within heterosexual relations. Texts from the opening years of the
twentieth century stressed the duty of the husband to court and
woo his wife and fulfill two distinct responsibilities: first, to
arouse his wife and second, to control his climax. This gendered
model of male as initiator and tutor and female as responding student
has proved remarkably persistent throughout the twentieth century.
The period between the two World Wars was decisive for the formation
of modern heterosexuality. Shifts in the prevailing sexual knowledge
induced significant changes in the normative prescriptions which
responsibilized husbands for ensuring the sexual pleasure of their
wives. The “sexual revolution” of the 1960s weakened
the link between sex and marriage as demonstrated, for example,
in the shift from “marriage” manuals to “sex manuals”
and the increasingly hedonistic quest for mutual sexual pleasure
through an emphasis on technique and the relocation of sex into
the realm of consumption. In addition, the new sexology of Kinsey
and Masters and Johnson insisted on the existence of strong female
sexual desire equal to that of men. However, the underlying discourse
emphasized polar differences between the sexes. The HIV/AIDS crisis
has continued to advance themes of responsibilization, normalization
and moralization where the new pattern of sexual advice moved decisively
toward themes of “risk” and “safety” through
the discourse of safer sex (The Canadian Journal of Human Sexuality,
2006; 15: 23-45). |